Friday, January 15, 2010

Responses to Week 1 Questionnaire

1.What is your favourite room or space in the school? What do you like
about this space?

The most popular responses are as follows:

The Yard –

Chill out and relax

Fresh air

Break from work

See friends

Spacious and open

Space to have fun

Place for exercise


Around the Bike Shed –

See friends

Sheltered

Warmest part of the yard

More privacy


Computer Room –

Play games

Do projects

Use the Internet

Have fun


Lunch Room –

Be yourself

Relax

Warm and comfortable

It's a sunny space



2. How important do you think the entrance to a school is? Why?


Most people felt the entrance to the school is important because:

It welcomes and entices people to come in

It is an access point

It is also an exit point!! (this is important especially in emergencies)

It is the first thing a visitor sees, it could even be considered as
one of the main attractions in the school!

It acts like a sign, it shows you where to enter the building

A decorated entrance sends out the right signals

Some felt it isn't important because:

It is simply a functional access point

Most action takes place in the classrooms.



3. Do you like the materials used in this school? Inside and Outside?


No. 44%

Yes. 56%

The negative responses are mainly because the materials are old and so
the school can be cold. More modern and contemporary materials could
be used to improve the school.



4. How should a school look from the outside?


Secure and safe

Modern, bright and clean

Welcoming and open

Big and warm

A happy place with lots of windows

It should make an impression and stand out from other buildings

It doesn't matter because it's about what the school does, not what it
looks like.

It should have a big grassy area and sports facilities for the students.

It should be well designed and well organised.



5. Do you like the size of the school at the moment? Would you prefer
it to be larger or smaller?


No. 21%

Yes. 79%

Generally most people are happy with the current size of the school,
particularly for the number of pupils. Here are some of the answers if
there was an opportunity to change the school:

If it were bigger there would be space for more facilities.

If it were bigger it would look out of place.

It should be one big building instead of two.

If it were bigger it would allow rooms for extra subjects e.g. woodwork



6. Can you think of a suitable site for a school in the local area?


Fairview Park

Beside the eye

Off the Alfie Byrne road

East Point

Beside Clontarf DART Station, due to its close proximity to town,
shops, train and gym.



7. Do you have a favourite building in Dublin? Can you name it, describe it?...


GPO – it is an impressive historically important building in the city

Liberty Hall – it is the tallest building in Dublin at the moment

The Docklands area – everything is modern here

Savoy Cinema – it's an old style cinema

Customs House – because of its positioning facing the river

State Street Building – it's a large building which looks as if it is
leaning backwards, covered in glass

Spire – a very tall piece of metal standing out from everything

Ha'penny Bridge – it is old, small and I like its shape and location

The O2 Arena – it looks old on the outside yet it's warm-looking inside.

Christchurch Cathedral

Chapters Book Store

Iliac Centre

UCI Cinema Parnell St.

Jervis Shopping Centre

Central Bank



Some buildings you might be interested in looking at in Dublin:

Trinity College

Bank of Ireland College Green – this was once where the Irish Parliament sat

Leinster House – current seat of the Irish Parliament

Smithfield and the Light house Cinema

Guinness Brewery

UCD main campus

The National Concert Hall

Stephen's Green shopping centre (look at the roof!)


If you are interested you could look at the work of some of the
following international architects.

Alvaro Aalto – Finlandia Hall, Helsinki, Finland

David Chipperfield – Sails and Winds Building, Valencia, Spain

Foster and Partners – Swiss Re London HQ (The Gherkin), London, UK

Frank Gehry – Guggenheim Museum, Bilbao, Spain

Frank Lloyd Wright – Falling Water, USA

Gaudi – Sagrada Familia, Barcelona, Spain

Herzog de Meuron – Tate Modern, London, UK

Jorn Utzon– Sydney Opera House, Australia

Le Corbusier – Unite d'Habitation, Marseille, France

Mies van der Rohe – Barcelona Pavilion, Spain

OMA – Hermitage Guggenheim, Las Vegas, USA

Richard Rogers – Centre Pompidou, Paris, France

Santiago Calatrava –Liffey Bridges, Milwaukee Art Centre,

Shigaru Ban – Paper Art Museum, Shizuoka, Japan

Toyo Ito – Sendai Mediatheque, Japan

Zaha Hadid – Bergisel Ski-jump, Innsbruck, Austria


Arup Engineers

Buro Happold Engineers

Peter Rice, an Irish architect originally from Dundalk, Co. Louth who
worked on the Pompidou centre and the Louvre in Paris as well as the
Sydney Opera House.



Some Irish Architects:

Boyd Cody

Donnaghy and Diamond

Grafton Architects

Heghenan Peng

Murray O'Laoire

O'Donnell and Tuomey

Scott Tallon Walker

Work to be completed for next meeting

Our next meeting with the team will be at 2pm Thursday 28th January.

For the meeting we would like the team to have the following pieces of work completed:


Firstly we would like the architecture team to divide into groups of 3. We will vary groups during the project.

We would then like each group to draw a plan of the existing school. This plan should express your ideas about each of the rooms and spaces. The plan does not have to be to scale, but you should try to have the rooms in proportion to each other, (if two rooms are the same size in reality they should be the same size on your plan!) little sketches and words can be written on the plan to give your ideas about the spaces e.g. Small, dark, open, fresh air etc. We will all look at the finished drawings at our next meeting.


On Thursday the 28th January we hope to explore Grand Canal Dock.

Notebooks, pens and pencils are required. Digital cameras would also be useful, it would be great if we could have one photographer per group.

Welcome to St. Joseph’s space for learning blog

Here we will be uploading our work from the Transition Year's architecture workshops. The aim of this competition is to design a space for learning using your ideas thoughts and responses.


Images, text, photos, drawings etc are all welcome. To upload material to the blog please email it to stjosephslearningspace (at) gmail.com


Any questions that you may have can be sent to the above email address. We welcome constructive comments from everyone and will value your support over the next six weeks.

We look forward to working with you.


Thank you

Áine and Monika